Title IX/ Title 9
Title IX is the 1972 federal law prohibiting sex discrimination in education programs receiving federal funding. Whether it also governs revenue-sharing payments is unsettled and actively contested. This is a fast-moving, legally uncertain area, and the guidance below is deliberately general: schools should rely on their own campus compliance office, legal counsel, and state-specific policy, since institution-specific facts drive the analysis. Our aim on this page is to explain what’s known and what isn’t, not to advise on how any individual school should resolve it.
What Title IX Requires in Athletics, Generally
Outside of revenue sharing, Title IX’s application to athletics is well established and unchanged by the House settlement. Schools are generally expected to satisfy one of three tests on participation opportunities: proportionality between the gender makeup of the student body and of athletes, a continuing history of expanding opportunities for the underrepresented sex, or full accommodation of that group’s interests and abilities. Separately, athletic scholarship dollars are expected to be distributed in proportion to participation rates by gender, and schools must provide equal treatment across areas like facilities, coaching, travel and support services. None of that changed with the settlement.
Does It Apply to Revenue Sharing? A Timeline of Shifting Guidance
Whether Title IX also governs how a school distributes its revenue-sharing pool is a genuinely open question, and federal guidance on it has moved in both directions in a short period. The Department of Education issued guidance in January 2025 stating that NIL payments were subject to Title IX proportionality requirements. That guidance was rescinded the following month. Neither position has settled the underlying legal question, and no binding resolution currently exists.
The Pending Ninth Circuit Appeal
The issue is also being litigated directly. Eight female athletes have challenged the settlement’s approach to revenue distribution, and an appeal is currently pending before the Ninth Circuit. However that appeal resolves, it has the potential to apply to decisions schools are making right now, which is part of why the issue is worth watching even while it remains unresolved.
How Roster Limits Intersect with Participation
Roster limits, adopted alongside revenue sharing, raise their own participation questions under the well-established side of Title IX, independent of how the revenue-sharing question resolves. A school reducing roster sizes in a given sport should evaluate that change against its existing participation-proportionality analysis the same way it always has, since that requirement has not changed.
What Schools Are Doing in the Meantime
Approaches vary by institution, and there isn’t a single accepted practice yet. Some schools have chosen to review their revenue-sharing distribution against traditional Title IX participation and scholarship metrics as a matter of caution, even without a legal requirement to do so; others are waiting for clearer guidance before changing their approach. Neither choice reflects a settled legal position, it reflects each institution’s own risk tolerance and its own counsel’s advice.
Where This Might Go
It’s genuinely unclear whether courts or a future rulemaking will ultimately extend Title IX’s proportionality framework to revenue-sharing payments, leave it outside that framework entirely, or land somewhere in between. Any of those outcomes is plausible based on where the guidance and litigation currently stand, and this page will be updated as that becomes clearer. In the meantime, the most reliable answer for any specific school is its own campus compliance office and legal counsel, applying the facts of that institution’s own program.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q. Does Title IX apply to revenue sharing?
Unresolved. Department of Education guidance issued in January 2025 said NIL payments were subject to Title IX proportionality requirements; that guidance was rescinded the following month. Neither position has settled the law.
Q. Is it being litigated?
Yes. Eight female athletes challenged the settlement’s revenue distribution, and an appeal is pending before the Ninth Circuit. The outcome could apply retroactively to decisions schools are making right now, which is part of why this bears watching even while it’s unresolved.
Q. What does Title IX definitely still cover?
Participation opportunities, athletic scholarship distribution, and equal treatment in facilities, coaching, travel and support. None of that changed, and roster limits have their own participation implications worth reviewing on their own terms.
Q. What should a school do in the meantime?
Talk to your own campus compliance office and legal counsel, and follow your state’s specific policy. This is not a one-size-fits-all answer, our aim here is to flag that the issue exists, not to advise on how to resolve it.
Q. Is there a “right side” of this debate that most schools are taking?
No single approach has become standard, and we don’t take a position on which outcome is correct. Institutions are making different choices based on their own counsel’s read of the risk, which is exactly why this is worth discussing with your own compliance office rather than assuming a industry-wide answer exists.
